Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Justin James's avatar

Best thesis I’ve read to explain this facet of oligarchy. Thanks also for sharing Gambetta’s work. Jon Elmer was right, with respect to your diverse thinking. I think this unofficial anti-genocide academy, here, is led and followed by diverse thinkers.

On rituals of humiliation, Syme wrote “Behind every monarchy lurks an oligarchy.”

The oligarchs don’t want a competent and independent monarch? Right, the peasants will bypass the oligarchs in desperation and appeal to the king. He can only do so much, he’s not a communist, and if he does anything he risks being killed or overthrown. And that’s why the Roman Republic was founded, despite what oligarchic propaganda would have us believe. Same principle applies to modern rulers in the West.

To tie your article to the resistance, now we all know why certain leaders are demonized. Anti-monarch and anti-oligarch leaders who refuse rituals of humiliation. A revolutionary. I’m neither Muslim nor communist. Maybe I should be! Thank you Mao, Lenin, Ayatollah, Castro, Kim il Sung, Al-Assad (senior especially, junior too), Nasrallah and Sinwar for refusing the West’s poisonous gifts, arming your people, and fighting the empire. I tell you the West really hates a colonial people who is not only decolonized but capable of fielding a conventional army to drive their mercenary hordes and fanatical auxiliaries into the sea. Honored to have visited south Lebanon to pay my respects to Nasrallah’s shrine in Dahiyah, who was assassinated for being impossible to humiliate.

Thanks for writing your article. Very helpful.

Expand full comment
Munch's avatar

No, I can't! In the UK, most of those elites(?!) go to boarding schools where those humiliation rituals take place, meaning they're exposed to those rituals from very young. On top, they don't grow up with their families. I don't think that you can expect them to act based on usual sense of love, compassion, empathy or moral even. This is not to justify their actions, but as you said, they are "0" competent, nothing more than ego maniac. Very harmful beings on the earth.

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts